8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
1/31
EBM diagnostic
Kanti Ratnaningrum
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
2/31
Skenario Klinis
• Seorang anak laki-laki umur 10 tahun datang kedokter dengan keluhan sakit tenggorokan. Sakittenggorokan dirasakan sudah lima hari. Sebagianbesar penyebab faringitis adalah irus. !ang
men"adi fokus perhatian dokter adalahmendiagnosis pasien apakah faringitis inidisebabkan oleh streptokokus #rup $ %#$S&. 'alini membutuhkan pemeriksaan kultur bakteri tapi
memerlukan (aktu lebih dari satu hari) untukmempercepat diagnosis) doktermempertimbangkan penggunaan pemeriksaanlain.
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
3/31
• *emeriksaankultur merupakan +gold standrat,
untuk mendiagnosis faringitis oleh karena #$S.aktu yang diperlukan untuk pemeriksaankultur ini sekitar /-/ "am.
• $ uantitatie polymerase chain reaction
%*2R& adalah teknik laboratorium biologimolekuler berdasarkan reaksi berantaipolimerase % *2R & yang dapat sedangdikembangkan.
• Sebelum dokter mempertimbangkan perubahanalur diagnosis pasien faringitis) sensiti3tas *2Rdibandingkan dengan pemeriksaan kultur untukmendeteksi #$S
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
4/31
Steps in Practicing EBM
1. Convert the need for information intoan answerable question.
. 4rack do(n the best eidence (ith (hich toans(er that uestion.
5. 2ritically appraise the eidence for itsalidity) impact) and applicability.
/. 6ntegrate the eidence (ith our clinicale7pertise and our patient’s characteristicsand alues.
8. Ealuating our e9ectieness and e:ciency ine7ecuting steps 1;/ and seeking (ays toimproe them both for ne7t time.
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
5/31
The clinical question:PICO
Patient orProblem
Intervention
Comparison
Outcome
$nakdengansuspek#roup $
streptococcus %#$S&
$uantitatiepolymerase
chainreaction%*2R&
#oldstandard<kultur
=iagnosisof faringitise.c #$S
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
6/31
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
7/31
Steps in Practicing EBM
1. 2onert the need for information into anans(erable uestion.
2. Track down the best evidence with
which to answer that question.5. 2ritically appraise the eidence for itsalidity) impact) and applicability.
/. 6ntegrate the eidence (ith our clinicale7pertise and our patient’s characteristics
and alues.8. Ealuating our e9ectieness and e:ciency ine7ecuting steps 1;/ and seeking (ays toimproe them both for ne7t time.
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
8/31
The search strategy
• *ubmed database<(http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/sites/ent rez?db=pubmed)
• ?sing the 2linical @ueries function of*ubMed< – Key (ords<
• “#$S” $A=
• “*2R”
– 2linical Study 2ategories< “=iagnosis”
– Scope< “Aarro(”
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
9/31
The Evidence
• =etection of group a streptococcalpharyngitis by uantitatie *2R
• =unne EM) Marshall C) Baker 2$) Manning ) #onis #) =anchin M') Smeesters *')SatDke 2) Steer $2. 015. =etection ofgroup a streptococcal pharyngitis byuantitatie *2R. BM2 6nfectious =iseases015) 15
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
10/31
Steps in Practicing EBM
1. 2onert the need for information into anans(erable uestion.
. 4rack do(n the best eidence (ith (hich to
ans(er that uestion.3. Critically appraise the evidence for itsvalidity, impact, and applicability.
/. 6ntegrate the eidence (ith our clinicale7pertise and our patient’s characteristics
and alues.8. Ealuating our e9ectieness and e:ciency ine7ecuting steps 1;/ and seeking (ays toimproe them both for ne7t time.
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
11/31
ppraising the Evidence
1. 6s this eidence about the accuracyof a diagnostic test alid>
. =oes this %alid& eidencedemonstrate an important ability ofthis test to accurately distinguishpatients (ho do and do not hae a
speci3c disorder>5. 2an 6 apply this alid) important
diagnostic test to a speci3c patient>
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
12/31
Is this evidence about the accuracy o! adiagnostic test valid"#$ Measurement
– as the reference %“gold”& standard measuredindependently>
!a %halm dari F&
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
13/31
Is this evidence about the accuracy o! adiagnostic test valid"%$ &epresentative
– as the diagnostic test ealuated in an appropriatespectrum of patients %those in (hom (e (ould use itin practice&>
!a
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
14/31
Is this evidence about the accuracy o! adiagnostic test valid"'$ scertainment
– as the reference standard ascertained regardless ofthe diagnostic test result>
!a
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
15/31
re the results o! this studyvalid"
• !a
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
16/31
ppraising the Evidence
1. 6s this eidence about the accuracyof a diagnostic test alid>
. =oes this %alid& eidencedemonstrate an important ability ofthis test to accurately distinguishpatients (ho do and do not hae a
speci3c disorder>5. 2an 6 apply this alid) important
diagnostic test to a speci3c patient>
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
17/31
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
18/31
4abel 7
spy12!
• Sensiti3tas< 1%1G5&. 100H FI benar-benar (+) G!
• Spesi3sitas< 105%0G105&.100H 100I benar-benar (-) G!• **J< 1%1G0&. 100H 100I
100I dari pasien yang dinyatakan %G& adalah benar disebabkan #$S
• A*J< 105%5G105&.100H FI
FI dari pasien yang dinyatakan %-& benar-benar tidak disebabkanoleh #$S
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
19/31
• Sensiti3tas 100I
• spesi3sitas 100I
• *realensi carier faringitis #$S 1I
%Shaikh A et al. 010&
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
20/31
ppraising the Evidence
1. 6s this eidence about the accuracyof a diagnostic test alid>
. =oes this %alid& eidencedemonstrate an important ability ofthis test to accurately distinguishpatients (ho do and do not hae a
speci3c disorder>5. 2an 6 apply this alid) important
diagnostic test to a speci3c patient>
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
21/31
re the results o! this diagnostic studyapplicable to my patient"
1. 6s the diagnostic test aailable)a9ordable) accurate) and precise in our
setting>• !a) akurat dan tersedia %tetapi tidak di semua
laboratorium&
• 4etapi tidak ter"angkau untuk semua pasien
%hanya keluarga kalangan menengah ke atas&• =an belum tepat dilakukan karena berbagai
pertimbangan
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
22/31
re the results o! this diagnosticstudy applicable to my patient"
. 2an (e generate a clinically sensibleestimate of our patient’s pre-testprobability>
a. Lrom personal e7perience) prealence statistics)practice databases) or primary studies.• !a
b. $re the study patients similar to our o(n>• !a
c. 6s it unlikely that the disease possibilities haechanged since this eidence (as gathered>
• !a
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
23/31
(i)elihood &atio
SpeB
• Likelihood Ratio+ = sens/(1-spec) = 100/(100-100) = ~• Likelihood Ratio- = (1-sens)/spec = (100-100)/100 = 0
• Pe!alence = (a+c)/(a+"+c+d) = #$/1#% = 1&'
• *td, pe-test odds = pe!alence/(1-pe!alence) = 1&'/&1'1 = #'
• Post-test odds = pe-test odds . likelihood atio = #' . * = ~
• Post-test po"a"ilit, = post-test odds/(post-test odds +1) = * / * = *
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
24/31
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
25/31
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
26/31
re the results o! this diagnosticstudy applicable to my patient"
5. ill the resulting post-testprobabilities a9ect our
management and help our patient>1. 2ould it moe us across a test-
treatment threshold>• !a) dari pre-test probability of 1.I ke
post-test probability of *
re the results o! this
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
27/31
re the results o! thisdiagnostic study applicable to
my patient"5. ill the resulting post-test probabilities
a9ect our management and help ourpatient> %cont.&
. ould our patient be a (illing partner incarrying it out>
• Mungkin iya
5. ould the conseuences of the test help ourpatient reach his or her goals in all this>
• !a) "ika hasil %-&) "ika hasil %G& dapat membantudalam hal pengobatan dan pencegahan komplikasiseperti =R$ dll
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
28/31
Steps in Practicing EBM
1. 2onert the need for information into anans(erable uestion.
. 4rack do(n the best eidence (ith (hich toans(er that uestion.
5. 2ritically appraise the eidence for itsalidity) impact) and applicability.
". #nte$rate the evidence with our clinicale%pertise and our patient ’ scharacteristics and values.
8. Ealuating our e9ectieness and e:ciency ine7ecuting steps 1;/ and seeking (ays toimproe them both for ne7t time.
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
29/31
+o, can I apply the results topatient care"
• 4es *2R spe" ini sangat bagus karena memilikisensiti3tas dan spesi3tas tinggi) sehingga dapatdigunakan untuk meningkatkan ketepatandiagnosis dan dan terapi serta mencegah
komplikasi
• 4es *2R mungkin tidak efektif dari segipembiayaan dan keter"angkauan karena tidaksemua laboratorium memiliki fasilitas *2R ini
• berbagai faktor harus dipertimbangkan sebelumpenggunaan tes *2R dalam strategi diagnosis)terapi dan pencegahan komplikasi
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
30/31
Steps in Practicing EBM
1. 2onert the need for information into anans(erable uestion.
. 4rack do(n the best eidence (ith (hich toans(er that uestion.
5. 2ritically appraise the eidence for itsalidity) impact) and applicability.
/. 6ntegrate the eidence (ith our clinicale7pertise and our patient’s characteristicsand alues.
. &valuatin$ our e'ectiveness ande(ciency in e%ecutin$ steps 1)" andseekin$ ways to improve them both forne%t time.
8/9/2019 Presentasi Dx
31/31
4erimakasih